The Guardian piece isn't saying it's a cause, but a contributing factor. I go for a sort of Chaos Theory approach to history - a meshing of factors and knock-on effects that every so often come together in a 'perfect storm' to create seismic (in the political sense of the word) events. Wet weather screws up a military campaign, a dry summer and the rivers run so low the mill wheels can't grind corn.
Are you American? You seem to be relating this to the way the US climate change debate has become politicised. I'm not from that cultural background (here I think generally climate change is accepted as a man-made or at any rate human-influenced phenomenon) and at no point in all the hours of TV discussion on the volcano has anyone said anything about it proving/disproving climate change, not even on the Murdoch-owned channels. The subject hasn't even been raised. I certainly wasn't relating the point in any way to that debate. If anything, though, volcanic eruptions make the case that climate change can be influenced by humans stronger: a discussion of the effect of atmospheric ash on historical famines can be related to the similar effect of human-created atmospheric pollutants.
![[community profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/community.png){kind=small}
![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png)
timeasmymeasure
no subject
Date: 2010-04-18 03:27 pm (UTC)Are you American? You seem to be relating this to the way the US climate change debate has become politicised. I'm not from that cultural background (here I think generally climate change is accepted as a man-made or at any rate human-influenced phenomenon) and at no point in all the hours of TV discussion on the volcano has anyone said anything about it proving/disproving climate change, not even on the Murdoch-owned channels. The subject hasn't even been raised. I certainly wasn't relating the point in any way to that debate. If anything, though, volcanic eruptions make the case that climate change can be influenced by humans stronger: a discussion of the effect of atmospheric ash on historical famines can be related to the similar effect of human-created atmospheric pollutants.