A good book about Saint-Just ?
May. 13th, 2008 08:25 pm![[identity profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/openid.png)
![[community profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/community.png)
Salut et Fraternité, Citoyennes et Citoyens !
I have been watching this community for a while and now I have decided to introduce myself and ask you a question.
I am greatly interested in French Revolution, with whom I have a strange relationship of love and hate - but I think this will be amusing to discuss another time.
Well, I am strangely, madly, deeply, lustfully, wildly, passionately in love with Saint-Just - yes - but in my mother language, Italian, there is rather only a few stuff upon him. So until now I only have had the chance to read Camus and Malraux essays which are available in my country.
I like these essays very, very much - I believe both the two existentialists reach a non-banal perspective of the character (even though they are men and miss the intuition of something only a woman can understand...), but I'd like to read more on my love.
I have read almost everything I have found on the Internet about him and now I would buy some foreign text more focused on his biography, since Camus and Malraux's are only short chapters drawn from more complex books and provide rather a general perspective on Antoine as a man and about his role in history of that age than pure biographical information.
I have seen there is an amount of biographies, but I have still not decided what to choose.
I can read English, French and German, and since I have a strong intellectual complexion due to my marxist education despite my reviewing it under a feminist, pagan, anarchist point of view, I'd like better a rigorous scientific account rather than a fiction-oriented one: in spite of his myth, Antoine is a man, first of all - and I am in love with him just because of this.
I have noticed Vinot's biography and I feel attracted to it but I am not absolutely sure - would you advice me to buy it ? And/or other texts ?
Just tell me whatever you believe to be useful.
Ok, I think this is enough for my first time here. Thank you in advance for your answers and comments - every suggestion is here absolutely welcome !
Au revoir,
F.
no subject
Date: 2008-05-13 09:05 pm (UTC)I am also greatly interested *coughseuphemism* with Saint-Just -- a postcard of his portrait by Prud'hon being precisely next to me. Um. I made a dissertation on him in my university course on the French Revolution, almost two years ago. Thus I've come across a few good articles and books. Vinot's biography is very good -- Ladret's too (Saint-Just ou les vicissitudes de la vertu, I think), because he gives extracts from other books written on Saint-Just and there's a good introduction on his origins. Also, I remember there are the texts from the symposium organised for the Bicentenial of his anniversary, in 1967, by Soboul. There are a few very good articles in there (like one, by J.-P. Gross, on the Saint-Just myth). J.-P. Gross also made a book about Saint-Just's missions.
I have bought Camus's book earlier this year -- I still have to read it. For now, I merely skipped through it. ;)
no subject
Date: 2008-05-13 09:59 pm (UTC)no subject
Date: 2008-05-13 10:36 pm (UTC)Vinot and Ladret's biographies are easily available on Internet bookshops and I believe I will buy one of them (or maybe both XD). I also have seen mentioned the texts gathered by Soboul somewhere but they are not on sale, at least now - it is a pity because Soboul is an excellent historian and I am sure he did a good job also in this case - so did you find this book in the library at the university ?
Then what about Curtis' biography ?
The first time I read of it, it was listed in the bibliography included by Mathiez in his history of the revolution. It is absolutely i-m-p-o-s-s-i-b-l-e to find it and this makes me sick-> is it really the more complete biography ever written about Antoine, Livvie ?
(if you answer me yes I cry...)(no subject)
From:no subject
Date: 2008-05-14 07:55 pm (UTC)On the concept of "revolution".
Beyond the excellent chapter about Antoine, it is one of the rare books you won't easily forget. At least this is my case.
$175 ? It is a deluxe edition ?
Stupid and exaggerated. Although I'd buy it anyway if only I found it out.
(and I cry, yeah)(no subject)
From:no subject
Date: 2008-05-14 11:45 pm (UTC)Quite boring, however.
(no subject)
From:(no subject)
From: